No Memorial?

15 Sep 2009 08:28 #1 by Paul Francis
No Memorial? was created by Paul Francis
When visiting Duxford yesterday with REF, I had pointed out the slab over the basement refuge of a Type 8/84 barrack block demolished just post war and which had been burnt out 19 July 1944 (I think that is correct).

The co-pilot of a B-17G from 401st BG at Deenthorpe flew his aeroplane over to Duxford to visit his brother Lt John Putnam of 84 FS. He gave a ride to several pilots and ground crew. Once airborne he decided to buzz the tower, skimming over the hangars, but failing to notice the neon beacon on top of the 84th Fighter Squadron hangar, which he clipped with a wing. Out of control the B-17 rolled over, narrowly missing the Officers' Mess and crashing into the 83rd FS barracks. Thirteen men died in the plane, including two pilots and eight enlisted me from Duxford. I think one died in the barrack block.

I may have got the above wrong and I am sure someone can correct it, if that is the case but this incident got me thinking that there must be many storys such as this where there is no memorial to the airmen and people on the ground who died. Therefore I wonder whether we shouldn't post them on here. I for one like reading about them and who knows someone may take note and erect a memorial plaque as a result.

You can tell a builder from an archaeologist by the size of his trowel. Mine is a small one!

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

15 Sep 2009 13:39 #2 by TommyUSA
Replied by TommyUSA on topic No Memorial?

... got me thinking that there must be many storys such as this where there is no memorial to the airmen and people on the ground who died. Therefore I wonder whether we shouldn't post them on here. I for one like reading about them and who knows someone may take note and erect a memorial plaque as a result.[/SIZE][/FONT]


I propose this memorial text:

Remembering the idiot that killed himself and a lot of other people by performing a dangerous and illegal stunt on this spot...


Seriously, if such memorials were placed, they do need to mention that the lives were lost due to carelessness, not enemy attack nor accident.

Tommy

.
Follow my World War II daily tweets at twitter.com/Sept1939

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

15 Sep 2009 15:21 #3 by Paul Francis
Replied by Paul Francis on topic No Memorial?
Yes your right Tommy but I was thinking more of the poor soles who lost their lives through no fault of their own. There must be other storys out there too.

I mean what if their surviving relatives came over here seeking more information and apart from Madingley, all there is left, is a slab of faceless concrete. Does not seem fair to me thats all.

You can tell a builder from an archaeologist by the size of his trowel. Mine is a small one!

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

15 Sep 2009 16:29 #4 by airfields man
Replied by airfields man on topic No Memorial?
There was talk of erecting a memorial at Duxford to the P38 Pilot who was killed at an airshow there about 10 years ago, This was in Flypast magazine. But to erect a memorial to each individual aircraft and crew member killed whist flying carelessly would be an impossible task,good idea that it is,there would be dozens at each operational aifield and even more at the training stations. Iv'e read of many such incidents over the years where a young 20 year old thought he would show everyone at the airfield just how good-a-pilot he is. Result one smoking crater and no remains !!

The Dead got memorials, The living got time.

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

15 Sep 2009 17:06 #5 by TommyUSA
Replied by TommyUSA on topic No Memorial?

I mean what if their surviving relatives came over here seeking more information and apart from Madingley, all there is left, is a slab of faceless concrete. Does not seem fair to me thats all.


I quite agree with that sentiment. Are there not already memorials to individual aircraft crashes here and there across the countryside? Seems like something to get a local history society on about.

Tommy

.
Follow my World War II daily tweets at twitter.com/Sept1939

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

27 Sep 2009 14:53 #6 by P Bellamy
Replied by P Bellamy on topic No Memorial?
The Duxford B-17 crash is something I was looking into a while back, due to the 401BG connection.
However, trying to identify the aircraft and crew has so far come up with nothing from the usual sources.

The "Duxford Diary" gives the date as 19th July 1944.
For that date the USAAF Overseas Accident reports list shows four 8AF B-17 losses:

B-17G 42-102937
412BS, 95BG.
Mid-air collision at base, 5 killed.
Pilot: Sasser, James D.
Location: Horham, AAF Stn 119.

B-17G 42-39973
730BS, 452BG.
Crash-landed at base, 3 killed.
Pilot: Gross, Morris L.
Location: Deopham Green, AAF Stn 142.

B-17G 43-37623
413BS, 96BG.
Mid-air collision, 3 killed.
Pilot: Colflesh, Ralph M.
Location, 1 mile west of Sheperds Grove.

B-17F 42-30851
560BS, 388BG.
Mid-air collision, 5 killed.
Pilot: Malaniak, Walter H.
Location: 6 miles east-northeast of Bury St Edmunds.

Checking the 401BG aircraft lists shows only one B-17 loss that day, 44-6129 IN-A of the 613BS, shot down over France after only 42 days with the unit.

More digging needed methinks.

TTFN,
PB

Paul Bellamy

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

27 Sep 2009 16:19 #7 by Paul Francis
Replied by Paul Francis on topic No Memorial?
It was from 612 BS.

You can tell a builder from an archaeologist by the size of his trowel. Mine is a small one!

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

27 Sep 2009 16:23 #8 by P Bellamy
Replied by P Bellamy on topic No Memorial?

It was from 612 BS.


That's just the thing, neither the 612th, or the 401st as a whole, lost an aircraft that day in the UK, and the USAAF's entire non-US records don't show it either.

It's a complete mystery at the moment.

All the best,
Paul

Paul Bellamy

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

28 Feb 2010 16:52 #9 by P Bellamy
Replied by P Bellamy on topic No Memorial?
Could this be the answer to the "what plane/unit" mystery?

From www.95thbg-horham.com/page319.html

42-102937 B17-G (READY FREDDIE)

This aircraft was assigned to the 412th BS 95th BG Horham 30/5/1944
It suffered a non-operational crash at Duxford, 19/7/1944, piloted by James D. Sasser resulting in fourteen deaths and two crew wounded.

Ivor Warne, "North Side Guide" at Duxford, in THIS article states:

On July 19, 1944, a B-17 pilot from the 612th Bomb Squadron, 401st Bomb Group based at Deenethorpe brought his aircraft, ‘Ready Freddie’, to visit an Eighth Air Force colleague at Duxford. They got chatting and decided to take some friends for a flight – it started off sedately, but with 13 on board the next thing was ‘Let’s buzz the tower’. They missed the tower and Hangar 3, but the left wing struck a beacon on the corner of the hangar. The B-17 cleared the Officers’ Mess, but hit the second barrack block – all 13 on board were killed, plus a serviceman who was the only one in the barracks that afternoon. That’s why there’s a big gap here. All that’s left is the entrance to the refuge.

Same aircraft name, 412th Bomb Squadron, 95th Bomb Group vs 612th Bomb Squadron, 401st Bomb group, same date.
Indeed, Lt. Sasser and two other men from his squadron killed that day still lay in Madingley.

Perhaps the guides at Duxford might consider amending the identity of the unit involved in this incident........

TTFN,
PB

Paul Bellamy

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

28 Feb 2010 18:01 #10 by Paul Francis
Replied by Paul Francis on topic No Memorial?
Nice to see the base and unit details cleared up. The port wing must have hit the beacon itself as there is no evidence seen today of any repairs to the concrete beacon platform. I had thought too that the angles and heights were all wrong but its quite possible that it would have cleared the officers mess, missed barrack block 213 and hit barrack block 211.

You can tell a builder from an archaeologist by the size of his trowel. Mine is a small one!

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

Time to create page: 0.053 seconds
Powered by Kunena Forum

We use cookies to improve our website and your experience when using it. Cookies used for the essential operation of this site have already been set. By continuing to use this site you are agreeing to this. To find out more about the cookies we use and how to delete them, see our privacy policy.

  
EU Cookie Directive Module Information