Airfield modelling (Airfix / Hornby / Lego etc)

14 Dec 2009 17:29 #41 by dangerousdave
Replied by dangerousdave on topic Airfield modelling (Airfix / Hornby / Lego etc)
Where is this thread going??? It's bad enough that I'm classed as an anorak plane spotter, but if I admit I hang around with people who collect models of control towers and train sets I'll have to make a noose and end it all!!

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

14 Dec 2009 18:16 #42 by Paul Francis
Replied by Paul Francis on topic Airfield modelling (Airfix / Hornby / Lego etc)
Dave, they are not train sets, they are model railways. It is not just a case of putting together a length of Hornby track and running a hogwarts express around it, some of us take pride in scratch-building military or civil scenes. I like modelling military dioramas for example LAA sites, pillboxes, hardened signal boxes and airfield buildings. Now that Hornby has released a 20-ton tank wagon in WD livery I might just include part of a fuel depot as well!

You can tell a builder from an archaeologist by the size of his trowel. Mine is a small one!

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

14 Dec 2009 18:18 #43 by Peter Kirk
Replied by Peter Kirk on topic Airfield modelling (Airfix / Hornby / Lego etc)
Dangerous talk Dave!

I collect dust :)

No Amount Of Evidence Will Ever Persuade An Idiot (probably not Mark Twain)

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

14 Dec 2009 21:10 #44 by Martin Bull
Replied by Martin Bull on topic Airfield modelling (Airfix / Hornby / Lego etc)

if I admit I hang around with people who collect models of control towers and train sets I'll have to make a noose and end it all!!


Thanks to this thread I've ordered one of these towers to go with my collection of 1/72 diecast aircraft......:oops:

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

14 Dec 2009 23:50 #45 by OneEighthBit
Replied by OneEighthBit on topic Airfield modelling (Airfix / Hornby / Lego etc)
Well this threads goes to the top of the "men in sheds" list for 2009 :D

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

15 Dec 2009 07:15 #46 by Martin Bull
Replied by Martin Bull on topic Airfield modelling (Airfix / Hornby / Lego etc)
I do get out occasionally.....

This image is hidden for guests.
Please log in or register to see it.

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

15 Dec 2009 09:53 #47 by Hornchurch
Replied by Hornchurch on topic Airfield modelling (Airfix / Hornby / Lego etc)
`

Martin,

I've just typed out a post/reply mentioning the above (now 'Legendary') shot !!!!!!!!!!!!
(in the Swannington/Mosquito-thread)

Makes sure ya post a duplicate of 'Bit O' Lace' (976), over in the Eastern airfields thread/section, eh ?

Oh, & those Lancaster/Airfield shots too (was it Metheringham ?)

Always brings a smile to my boat that 'Bit O' Lace'/Rattlesden shot !!!!!!!!!!!!

p.s. I STILL prefer the Airfix Control-Tower = the Skaledale looks too 'skinny' to me.

`

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

19 Dec 2009 08:50 #48 by Martin Bull
Replied by Martin Bull on topic Airfield modelling (Airfix / Hornby / Lego etc)
OK, I've briefly emerged from my potting shed to deliver this learned report to the AiX.....:lol:

Thanks to Paul Francis' superb book 'Control Towers' ( Airfield Research 1993 ) I can identify the Hornby tower as being a vague effort at portraying a 'civilianised' Watch Office for Bomber Satellite Stations 13726/41 - of which a prime example is cited as that of one of my favourite airfields, Little Staughton.

Here's a genuine, anorak-style comparison...

This image is hidden for guests.
Please log in or register to see it.



This image is hidden for guests.
Please log in or register to see it.



As can easily be seen, Hornby haven't got it right. Apart for the obvious lack of a side window, the building simply isn't deep enough front-to-rear ; a complete set of rooms has been left out.

It's not totally beyond redemption - it bears a passing resemblance - but what with this and the Airfix effort, I wish someone from 'Cornby' would just get up to East Kirkby, take a few photos and drawings, and give us a proper WWII Watch Office for All Commands....:(

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

19 Dec 2009 10:40 #49 by Paul Francis
Replied by Paul Francis on topic Airfield modelling (Airfix / Hornby / Lego etc)
Excellent comparison shots Martin. I totally agree that there should be an affordable accurate model on the market. Flightline do one which is brass-etched (12779/41) but as with all models made from this medium, it is very expensive.

I wonder how Hornby could get it so wrong, I can understand why Airfix got it wrong as the model has been around since the 1960s but Hornby started with a clean sheet as it were.

You can tell a builder from an archaeologist by the size of his trowel. Mine is a small one!

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

19 Dec 2009 10:54 #50 by REF
Thanks for the comparrison shots Martin.

I can only agree with what you and Paul have already said above!

Perhaps you'd like to put a little bit more together with the photos above for a "review" in the next Airfield Review??

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

Time to create page: 0.052 seconds
Powered by Kunena Forum

We use cookies to improve our website and your experience when using it. Cookies used for the essential operation of this site have already been set. By continuing to use this site you are agreeing to this. To find out more about the cookies we use and how to delete them, see our privacy policy.

  
EU Cookie Directive Module Information